TED
CHIANG: I tend to think that most fears about A.I. are best understood
as fears about capitalism. And I think that this is actually true of
most fears of technology, too. Most of our fears or anxieties about
technology are best understood as fears or anxiety about how capitalism
will use technology against us. And technology and capitalism have been
so closely intertwined that it’s hard to distinguish the two.
Let’s
think about it this way. How much would we fear any technology, whether
A.I. or some other technology, how much would you fear it if we lived
in a world that was a lot like Denmark or if the entire world was run
sort of on the principles of one of the Scandinavian countries? There’s
universal health care. Everyone has child care, free college maybe. And
maybe there’s some version of universal basic income there.
Now
if the entire world operates according to — is run on those principles,
how much do you worry about a new technology then? I think much, much
less than we do now. Most of the things that we worry about under the
mode of capitalism that the U.S practices, that is going to put people
out of work, that is going to make people’s lives harder, because
corporations will see it as a way to increase their profits and reduce
their costs. It’s not intrinsic to that technology. It’s not that
technology fundamentally is about putting people out of work.
It’s
capitalism that wants to reduce costs and reduce costs by laying people
off. It’s not that like all technology suddenly becomes benign in this
world. But it’s like, in a world where we have really strong social
safety nets, then you could maybe actually evaluate sort of the pros and
cons of technology as a technology, as opposed to seeing it through how
capitalism is going to use it against us. How are giant corporations
going to use this to increase their profits at our expense?
And
so, I feel like that is kind of the unexamined assumption in a lot of
discussions about the inevitability of technological change and
technologically-induced unemployment. Those are fundamentally about
capitalism and the fact that we are sort of unable to question
capitalism. We take it as an assumption that it will always exist and
that we will never escape it. And that’s sort of the background
radiation that we are all having to live with. But yeah, I’d like us to
be able to separate an evaluation of the merits and drawbacks of
technology from the framework of capitalism.